I think it's worth reading into it more as the problem is usually frame times - not the average frame rate.
A display has a refresh rate in Hz, e.g. 30/60/120 per second (which is 1000 milliseconds).
A "smooth" 60fps game delivers each new frame at exactly 1000/60 = ~16ms. A smooth 30fps at exactly 1000/30 = ~33ms.
The problem is many 30fps games this generation have rubbish frame pacing that alternates between delivering frames at 16, 33, and 50ms even if the average reading on a graph comes out at 30fps.
It results in stuttering similar to what you might see if you use a 40fps mode on a 60Hz display. 30fps on 60Hz is perfect as it just displays 1 frame for 2 refreshes (30x2=60). At 40fps, it delivers 1 frame for 2 refreshes, 1 frames for 1 refresh and repeats as 60/40=1.5. Even if it's a "smooth" 40fps, it doesn't feel that way.
@Blaze
Most reviews for this (as per Metacritic) is relegated to PlayStation. And odds are, most reviewers are doing it on the Pro, so they are likely getting the best version of the game. That likely isn't the experience that a majority of the playerbase will have, that will be on base PS5. We're not even talking about the Series S.
As for the 30 fps, although some of us, like yourself, can agree it isn't an issue always, @DP is correct in how there's a double standard for it. Look at the backlash that Bloodwalker got for a 30-40fps launch and that was a smaller studio, launching their first title. Yet Rockstar has a pass for having mid-20s drops.
WD sent over one of their officially licensed PlayStation branded NVMEs for review recently and I had the opportunity to put it through its paces just to see how good it actually is. Sporting a sleek black finish and the iconic PlayStation logo on the heatsink, the WD Black SN850P is a cool piece of tech that really does look premium.
Does it live up to the hype, though? And more importantly, should you pick this up if you’re looking for a PS5 compatible NVME drive?
First and foremost, here are the technical specifications of the WD Black SN850P:
- 1TB Solid State Drive
- PlayStation 5 Ready Pre-Installed Heatsink
- Form Factor: M.2 2280
- Interface: Interface4 Pcie® Gen4 16gt/S, Up To 4 Lanes
- Nand Western Digital® Tlc 3d Nand
- Sequential Read Speed: Up to 7,300MB/s
- Sequential Write Speed: Up to 6,300MB/s
- Random Read (up to): 800K IOPS
- Random Write (up to): 1,100K IOPS
- Endurance Rating: 600TBW
- MTTF: Up to 1.75 Million Hours
- 5 Year Warranty
With that out the way, let’s dive right in. This is a PlayStation branded and officially endorsed NVME drive and as such, it will work straight out of the box when installed in a PlayStation 5 console. I’ll circle back to this in a bit since what I really wanted to see here is how the NVME performed in a PC when under load from a benchmarking tool like CrystalDiskMark.
Unboxing the device was straightforward and it sits snugly inside a cardboard and plastic container with a blue PlayStation aesthetic. There’s no confusion here, this is clearly a PlayStation marketed product.
The drive itself is quite small as expected from the NVME form factor but notably has a chunky heatsink. This is incredibly important for the PlayStation 5 while it’ll be less so for PCs with adequate cooling systems in place. With that said, under load, your mileage will obviously vary depending on ambient temperatures and how hot your system runs in general. Rest assured though that inside a PlayStation 5 device, this NVME with its chunky heatsink will be perfectly fine.
Installing the NVME in my PC was a breeze. Simply push it into the M.2 2280 slot and tighten the screw to secure it in place. Getting it to run on PC does need you to format it and partition it accordingly but this is done via Disk Management in a few simple steps. If you are a complete computer newbie, you can also find some great support and instructions on Western Digital’s support website here. It’s very straightforward though. Once you’ve set up the drive and your OS detects it, you’re good to go. Easy peasy!
After installing the NVME, I immediately opened up CrystalDiskMark 8.04 Shizuku Edition (Anime fans rise up!) and ran all 4 benchmark tests 4 times to obtain an average score for each test. The results of this can be seen below:
Interestingly, the real world performance of the drive averaged out over 4 consecutive tests at 6929.99 MB/s Read and 6380.84 MB/s Write. This is pretty much in-line with the manufacturer’s claims with the Write speed actually being a tiny bit higher in this case on average. CrystalDiskInfo showed the device’s vital information as below:
Since this is a PlayStation targeted NVME I had to test it in my PS5 console it and this was also a breeze to do. You need to simply pop off the plastic outer shell of the PS5 to expose the M.2 slot and simply insert the NVME into it and tighten a screw. The exact same process as installing it on a PC but this time, just on a console. Once you reconnect your PS5 and boot it up, it will immediately detect the drive and ask you to format it for use with the console. Once you do this it will also tell you its expected Read speed and you’re good to go.
To test the speed of the drive, I first transferred over 150GB of installed game files over to the NVME from the console’s internal storage. This took less than 30 seconds to do which is blisteringly fast. I’m not sure what I was expecting but it certainly was not that! Being used to seeing files copying for ages across standard SATA hard drives and external drives on console clearly psychologically conditioned me into expecting to wait much longer. Transferring 150gb of game files so quickly on a console was mind-blowing to say the least.
Before transferring my files though I did do some basic testing with the PS5’s internal storage by loading up Final Fantasy VII Remake. I timed the loading time to go from opening the game to getting into a playable state in-game. This came in at 16.36 seconds. After transferring the game files to the SN850P and launching the game I did the exact same thing. To my surprise it only took me 9.90 seconds to get into the game in a playable state. Thus, the blisteringly fast NVME shaved off a whole 6 and a half seconds in loading time.
I tested this with another game too however, this one didn’t show such a significant change but this is partly due to the network features being essential to the game. Monster Hunter Wilds opened up to a playable state in 1 minute 23.88 seconds with the PS5’s internal drive. When moved to the NVME, it took 1 minute 21.70 seconds. Sure it’s 2 seconds faster but the real bottleneck with this game is the fact that you need to connect to the PlayStation Network for an online session which slows things down quite a bit.
Therefore, it can be concluded that the NVME can and will make a difference to your loading times with games that do not require online services. If you want to shave off a good few seconds in loading times, install your games on the NVME since it’s clearly a lot faster than the PS5’s internal storage which runs at 5500 MB/s Read.
With all the testing out the way the real question that needs answering now is, is the SN850P worth it? Coming in a hefty price point that fluctuates between R3,899 and R4,219 depending on which retailer you’re purchasing from, this drive is extremely pricey, all things considered. Yes, you’re getting the PlayStation endorsement and branding here but it comes at a premium. Users may want to do some research into alternative drives which have the same Read and Write speeds and come in at a lower price point. The added heatsink is a benefit here but you can quite literally purchase cheap third party heat sinks and add them to standard heatsink-less NVMEs yourself nowadays for a fraction of the cost.
Overall, the WD Black SN850P is a drive that ticks all the right boxes and lives up to its claims. It’s an excellent product that’s well-designed and clearly does its job well. However, in the South African market it has a lot of tough competition from other manufacturers who have NVMEs priced significantly lower per GB in general and users will find alternatives without much effort. Only get this drive if you absolutely MUST have a PlayStation endorsed NVME otherwise, look to competitors like Samsung or Crucial instead and you’ll find cheaper alternatives that are just as fast. Interestingly, the WD Black SN850X which also works in the PS5, has an RGB light and is basically the same drive is cheaper, so WD are competing with themselves here too.