Saw people talking[censored] about it online, it's always the people with no experience that talk the most BS

we don't know the condition of the cards, just because they went straight out the pack doesn't mean anything, the pack could have been bent, edges could not have been sharp, they could have been an indent on them etc. Picking up most comics off the shelf at an LCS and you will be lucky to hit a 9.0 when grading. Most are 8.5 or lower, I have to go through handfuls to find anything that will break a 9.0